Proverb Lore Many sayings, wise or otherwise, on many subjects, gleaned from many sources — A Reader’s Guide

(0 User reviews)   352
In Category - Language Study
Hulme, F. Edward (Frederick Edward), 1841-1909 Project Gutenberg 2010 Not confirmed
Proverbs -- History and criticism Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 90,286
Reading time 393 min
Text sections 12

Proverb Lore Many sayings, wise or otherwise, on many subjects, gleaned from many sources — A Reader’s Guide can be approached with a clearer sense of reading commitment from its source measurements: 90,286 words, 6 hr 33 min estimated reading time, and 12 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 28.9 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Proverbs -- History and criticism,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

An examination of proverbs from ancient to modern times, focusing on their origins, definitions, and the trades and moral lessons they reflect, based on excerpts from Hulme's 1902 collection.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.9/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

verbs to be found in the early Greek and Roman writers. The book is a monument of perseverance and erudition; it still remains unrivalled, and it became on its issue the medium through which the knowledge of many proverbs was disseminated throughout Europe: the similarity of many of the proverbs of England, Holland, Germany, Italy, Spain, was at least in some measure owing to the fact that the Latin treatise of Erasmus supplied an abundant store for general appropriation.

Erasmus was one of the many who sought to reform the Church. The dissolute were denounced whatever their rank, and abuses were fulminated against with unsparing zeal, so that the people were prepared for some great change either of mending or ending. Hence it has been said that Erasmus laid the egg of the Reformation and Luther hatched it. Great enmity was aroused, and the divines who had had cause to wince, endeavoured to persuade the Pope, Leo X., to have the "Adagia" condemned. The morals and comments added to some of the proverbs told very heavily against the clergy, and they very naturally did not take kindly to the issue of such a book. The ecclesiastics, however, in session at the Council of Trent, before whom the matter was brought, liberally decided that the book was of too great value to be wholly suppressed, so they contented themselves with ordering its strict revision, everything which they deemed offensive to the papal sway and the influence of the priesthood being under their ban. This garbled version was published in Florence in the year 1575, the name of the author being suppressed, but the book had ere this passed through so many editions and had been scattered so far and wide over Europe that any action of this kind came altogether too late to be of any efficacy.

Taverner, an Englishman, issued a book of proverbs, axioms, and epigrams in the year 1539. It is in black-letter, and has avowedly been largely constructed "with newe addicions" out of the monumental work of Erasmus. It is "the Garden of Wysdome, conteyning pleasant floures, that is to saye, propre and quycke sayinges of Princes, Phylosphers, and other sortes of men, Drawen forth of good Authours by Rycharde Tauerner." His comments on the various adages are often very shrewd. "Lawes," he says, "be lyke spyders webbes, wherein the weakest and most feble beastes be catched and stycke faste, but the strongest breake out. So lawes do bynde the poore and meane persons but the rich cobbes escape vnpunyshed"; and again, "An angrye bodye dothe nothynge dyffer from a mad man, but in the tariannce of tyme, sygnifyeng that wrathe is a short frensye." Many of his "quycke sayinges"[35:A] are very happy, thus, "Demanded what is a frend, Zeno answered an other I, sygnifyeng that an entyer and hartye frende no lesse loveth his frende then hymselfe." We read, too, with interest, of "a certayne person which rose erly in the mornynge and found his hose knawen and eaten of the rattes, and being troubled wyth this syght, thynkyng it a prognosticatiō (a tokē of some misfortune) he cometh to Cato to aske his coūsaile and to know of hym what euyl thys thyng portended. Cato maketh hym thys answere, Certes my frend it is no mōstrouse syght to se rattes eat mens hose, but yf thy hose had eaten the rattes that had been a monstrouse syght." This answer was so entirely to the point that one would fain hope that the man of the knawen hose went on his way rejoicing that he knew the worst.

Books of like nature with that of Taverner will be found in the works of Florio--one of these is entitled "Merie proverbes, Wittie Sentences and golden Sayings," and another is the "Garden of Recreation." This latter contains some six thousand Italian proverbs. They doubtless passed through divers editions; the copies that came under our own notice were dated 1578 and 1591 respectively.

Hulme opens his study by asserting that proverbs offer 'one-sided views of truth' and often contradict each other, a claim borne out in the excerpts. He organizes material by subject—carpentry, barbering, tailoring, cobbling—rather than by chronology or region, giving the work a practical, trade-by-trade structure. The catalog subject 'Proverbs -- History and criticism' is accurate, but the excerpts reveal that Hulme is less concerned with critical analysis than with amassing illustrative examples and tracing their appearances in literature from Chaucer to Shakespeare.

Definitions and Contradictions

Hulme begins by acknowledging the difficulty of defining a proverb, citing various writers and emphasizing brevity, hyperbole, and figurativeness as essential traits. He notes that proverbs often present 'one-sided views of truth' and may contradict each other—a point he illustrates without providing specific contradictory pairs in the excerpts. The chapter on definitions draws on classical and biblical sources, including the Proverbs of Solomon and Ecclesiasticus, but the excerpts do not detail how these sources are used. Hulme’s approach is descriptive rather than analytical: he collects definitions rather than interrogating them.

Trades and Their Sayings

The excerpts devote considerable space to proverbs from specific occupations. Carpenters contribute 'To go against the grain' and 'A bad workman finds fault with his tools.' Barbers are linked to the Roman adage 'Omnibus notum tonsoribus' and the English 'Every barber knows that.' Tailors are the subject of 'It takes nine tailors to make a man,' which Hulme traces to a 1630 poem, noting the poet’s disagreement. Cobblers yield 'The cobbler's wife is the worst shod,' with a medieval verse quoted. These examples show Hulme’s method: he anchors each proverb in a trade, cites a literary source, and occasionally offers mild commentary, as when he dismisses the poet’s counter-claim about tailors.

Moral and Religious Proverbs

A substantial portion of the excerpts presents proverbs with moral or religious weight. Hulme praises 'Make a crutch of your cross' and warns that 'He who thinks to deceive God has already deceived himself.' He links the ancient idea of Nemesis to the proverb 'Fate moves with leaden feet, but strikes with iron hands' and its later variant 'The mill of God grinds slowly but it grinds exceeding fine.' The hypocrite is addressed with 'Religion is the best armour in the world, but the worst cloak.' These examples demonstrate Hulme’s tendency to treat proverbs as timeless wisdom, though he does not critically examine their cultural or historical contexts.

Sources and Collections

Hulme surveys historical collections of proverbs, from the 'Adagia' of Erasmus and Heywood’s collection to Herbert’s 'Jacula Prudentum' and Franklin’s 'Poor Richard.' He notes the difficulties of classification by country, leading word, or subject. The excerpts do not provide detailed analysis of any single collection; instead, Hulme lists them in a catalog-like manner. His own work appears to be a compendium rather than a scholarly critique, drawing on these predecessors without evaluating their methods.

Readers should approach this book as a Victorian anthology of proverbs, not a systematic study. Hulme’s strength lies in the breadth of his examples, but his commentary is often light. The excerpts suggest that the work is best used as a reference for tracing proverbs to literary sources, with the understanding that Hulme’s interpretations reflect his own moral outlook. For critical analysis, supplementary sources are advisable.

Reading through Proverb Lore, I kept noticing how each saying is a tiny, worn key to a whole way of thinking. It reminded me of my old habit of flipping through Putnam's Word Book A Practical Aid in Expressing Ideas Through the Use of an Exact and Varied Vocabulary — A Closer Reading, where every word waits patiently for the right moment. Both feel like quiet rooms full of familiar, good company.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.

Reader reflection

Take a moment to reflect on this book

Create a short personal record of your experience with this book.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

How far have you progressed with this book?

2

How much did you enjoy the reading experience?

3

Would you pass this book on to a friend?

4

How easy was the book to follow?

Related eBooks